I like the NYC one, because some of your friends and family may not know where you'll be getting married, since you're now both in Germany -- just my two cents :)
I agree with the new york city one!
I like the NYC the best!
I like the second one best, but you do have a Manhatten skyline in the background at the restaurant, so it fits with that theme. Not much help, am I? LOL
I live NYC too!
I like #1 :)
I like the NYC one!
I like the second one, because of the formality. The first one is cute, but think it's a little too cute...
the NYC one, definitely
LOVE the NYC one!
love them both but the NY one is my fav :)
I love the second one!
Depends what look you are going after for your wedding. If you are doing elegant, i would do the 2nd. Fun - i would do the first!
I love the first! It's more formal and elegant and sets a great tone for the rest of the wedding.
They're both so good-looking, it's hard to decide. I like the NYC one but possibly with a different font for the couple's names?
I LIKE the first one :-) esp for a magnet~~
I love love love the first one! It is so classy!
The first one :) I know how much you are enjoying all this wedding planning! xo
I think it depends on the "feel" you are going for with your wedding. If you are going for more classic, I like the second, but for more fun the first is great! Basically, I agree with Annie above :)
I love the NYC one!!!
i like the NYC one too...so unique!
I love the first. NYC hands down!!!!
I like the NYC one because it's unique!
NYC/First one, very classy & perfect for a STD magnet!
I would go with choice #2! I bet it looks great in shades of blue
LOVE the NYC one and it seems to really go with your location of the wedding and that great view you spoke of! Plus, I agree with what Heidi said - some people may not know where you are getting married so this will be a great way to let them in on that particular detail!